EN | NL | FR
Current Wings Quest 132
2020 Vision

Language Recall in Dreams

Post new topic Reply to topic

Author  Message 
Lisez Lelui
Lucid Initiate
Lucid Initiate
Posts: 63
Joined: 08 Dec 2018
Last Visit: 27 Jan 2020
LD count: 8
Location: Kentucky
Language Recall in Dreams
PostPosted: Sat 08 Jun, 2019  Reply with quote

I've heard many people claim that they sometimes dream in languages besides their native one that they've learned -- some even say that "you aren't truly fluent until you can do this." What perplexes me is that despite being decently fluent in French and semi-"fluent" in Latin (though Latin is of course a special case), I've never had a dream where any intelligible conversation was held by means of these two languages. In fact, I recently had one where I failed to recall basic Latin words I had known since my first year of learning the language:

Lisez Lelui wrote:
Dream Language Amnesia

I was with a crowd of people who asked me what "I hope for you" would be in Latin. This is an extraordinarily simple sentence, and I would have been able to answer the question instantly in WL. They wanted to know so that they could yell it at another group of people who were leaving to do something dangerous. I struggled to remember the verb "to hope," coming up with the pathetic "hopere" before eventually having a flash of insight: "I hope" translated as "spero." At no point did I actually remember the infinitive "to hope," which is "sperare." I combined this with the ablative (singular!) form of "you," "te," and proceeded to tell them the sentence was "Spero te," which they went on to say. I then thought (and this is really inexplicable), "Maybe I should have told them 'petite pro vos' (Pray for yourselves, but "vos" should have been "vobis") instead."

Has anyone else ever had anything like this happen to them?

This occurrence sheds some interesting light on the way memory works in dreams. I've almost never spoken or heard either French or Latin while dreaming, and when I have, it's generally been me overhearing garbled, nonsensical sentences that I vaguely comprehend and responding with modified stock phrases. For example, "petite pro nobis" is a standard request for intercession by various saints, and my mind must have just slotted in the necessary "vos" for the sentence to remotely make sense in context. Similarly, I only knew "spero" from some college motto that goes "dum spiro, spero." I also seem to just never encounter French in general, despite being more fluent in it than in Latin. I never have any trouble remembering how to speak English in dreams -- I wonder why this is...

Current LD goal(s): Achieve stable lucidity; Have a conversation with myself

Link to My DJ: ld4all.com
back to top
Cornelia Xaos
cookie lover
cookie lover
Cornelia Xaos has successfully completed an LD4all Quest!
Posts: 2316
Joined: 09 Oct 2009
Last Visit: 17 Feb 2020
LD count: 391—20/02/16
Location: I'll give you a hint: it's got a blue background with stars, and it's a forum...
PostPosted: Sat 08 Jun, 2019  Reply with quote

I don't know what to tell you.. What I can do is offer anecdotes of my own. If you peruse my DJ you may find I use a occasionally speak in other languages.. though it may be like a 1 in 100 or 200 kind of thing.. unless it was heavily on my mind during the week leading up to the dream.

I can say, however, that when I haven't known how to say something IWL I didn't know how to say it in dream either. I've also had "nonsense" words used for languages I don't know.. and somehow I've understood them.. But what's really crazy..

.. is that I've had full on conversations in Spanish that, when I can recall the dialogue, end up making sense IWl! I've had a few one-liners in Japanese.. but nothing as profound as my Spanish.

I should note that when it comes to Spanish, I studied it for 6 years in grade school, and studied abroad for four months in Colombia in college where I used Spanish 97% of the time. I lived the language at that point.. so that definitely aided in my ingraining of the language.

This makes me want to set a lucid goal to have a dream where I become lucid and "convert" the dreamworld to Spanish to see what happens.

Current LD goal(s): Summon Lynn for a Tea Party.

Link to My DJ: ld4all.com
back to top
Dream Deity
Posts: 701
Joined: 28 Jun 2012
Last Visit: 15 Feb 2020
LD count: 11.8 estimate
PostPosted: Sun 09 Jun, 2019  Reply with quote

For the languages I learned as a child and use on a more or less daily basis IWL, I remember just fine in dreams just like English. For the other languages I'm learning but not really using, I've only dreamt of simple phrases or even just words or characters, not necessarily correct. Sometimes I dream of something being in a certain language, but don't remember it well enough when I wake up to know if it was correct or not. I just know it was in that language.

back to top
Posts: 237
Joined: 27 Jun 2003
Last Visit: 15 Jul 2019
Location: Pittsburgh, PA., US.
PostPosted: Mon 10 Jun, 2019  Reply with quote

My guess is that how much and how well you understand and use a given language in a dream is directly correlated to how much you're using it casually in your day-to-day waking life, and how much you've used it in the past.

For example, I took Japanese classes for years without ever dreaming in it, but after I had been living in Japan for a couple months I did start to have dreams in it sometimes, and I continued to now and again even after coming back to the States. This is true even though I never got as far as fluent, just decently conversational. I think it's because I was actually surrounded by the language while I was there, so when my brain was sifting through my memories to generate dreams out of there was a lot of "Japanese language stuff" in the recent past to draw on. Similarly, I still use my Japanese skills online every day, but my day-to-day life has been happening in English for years and years now, so it's pretty rare that Japanese shows up in my dreams. I bet that if I went back to Japan, stayed for a long time, and made an effort to use Japanese as my primary language, it would start turning up in my dreams a lot. I also bet that even if I spent years in Japan speaking mainly Japanese, I would still dream in English sometimes, just because I have so many memories where English was the primary language in use.

It makes sense to me that your dreams wouldn't have strong Latin content even if you spend a lot of time studying Latin, just because I don't think you're in an environment where everyone is speaking Latin all the time. Maybe if you went to some sort of intensive Latin study retreat where everyone was required to use Latin for day-to-conversation, you would have some dreams in it and be able to use it confidently in them.

back to top
Display posts from previous:
Post new topic Reply to topic


All times are GMT + 2 Hours
Jump to:  

Powered by phpBB
LD4all ~ spreading the art and knowledge of lucid dreaming online since 1996 ~